Review: Ruby Red by Kerstin Gier

Title: Ruby Red (The Ruby Red Trilogy #1)

Author: Kerstin Gier

Rating: *****

ISBN: 978-0-312-55151-3

Publisher: Square Fish (An imprint of MacMillan)

Genre: Young Adult - Fiction - Fantasy - Time Travel - Romance

Source: Library

---

Summary: From Goodreads: "Gwyneth Shepherd's sophisticated, beautiful cousin Charlotte has been prepared her entire life for traveling through time. But unexpectedly, it is Gwyneth, who in the middle of class takes a sudden spin to a different era!

Gwyneth must not unearth the mystery of why her mother would lie about her birth date to ward off suspicious about her ability, brush up on her history, and work with Gideon - the time traveler from a similarly gifted family that passes the gene through its male line, and whose presence becomes, in time, less insufferable and more essential. Together, Gwyneth and Gideon journey through time to discover who, in the 18th century and in contemporary London, they can trust."

---

Thoughts: I loved this book. I had a few qualms, which I will address in a moment, but overall the story was incredibly fast paced and engaging. Gwyneth makes a wonderful heroine. You sympathize with her and want to be her at the same time. Though, maybe minus the creepy counts and secretive societies.

I did have trouble, rather like Gwyneth, with keeping track of how much time had passed between each event. And I felt like Gideon became less repulsive a little too fast. Those were my two qualms with the book, I prefer relationships to develop a little more realistically.

I think Kerstin Gier did a great job of making you go through a lot of the emotions and questions that Gwyneth was going through. Loving and loathing characters as she learned to love and loath them. Her world was completely believable and I just wanted to keep being drawn deeper and deeper in to it.

Gier created a magnificent and believable history for her secret society. I really did believe that this society could exist and that the records they were speaking of were complete. That was key to my enjoyment of the book. If there had been loop holes or inconsistencies, then I would have tired of it very quickly. However, since the history behind the group seemed so tangible, it was easy to slip in and believe that Gwyneth really was thrust in to something over her head.

I also loved that, though the book was a translation, the translator did such an amazing job at translating it, I never once thought about the fact that it was a translation until I was sitting down to write this review. Rushing to get my hands on the next one now!

---

Favorite Quote(s):
- I was terribly excited when I climbed into the hopped petticoat. "This feels just like carrying a birdcage around with me."

- "That was incredibly reckless and...dreadfully dangerous and..." He swallowed hard and stared at me. "And, dammit all, rather brave of you."

---

What are some other time travel books you like?

- Faye

Review: Fablehaven by Brandon Mull

Title: Fablehaven (Fablehaven #1)

Author: Brandon Mull

Rating: ****

ISBN: 978-1-59038-581-4

Genre: Young Adult - Fiction - Fantasy - Adventure - Magic

Source: Library

---

Summary: From Goodreads: "For centuries, mystical creatures of all description were gathered to a hidden refuge to prevent their extinction. The sanctuary survives today as one of the last strongholds of true magic in a cynical world. Enchanting? Absolutely. Exciting? You bet. Safe? Well, actually, quite the opposite... Kendra and her brother Seth have no idea their grandfather is the current caretaker of Fablehaven. Inside the gated woods, ancient laws give relative order amoung greedy trolls, mischievous satyrs, plotting witches, spiteful imps, and jealous fairies. However, when the rules get broken, an arcane evil is unleashed, forcing Kendra and Seth to face the greatest challenge of their lives. To save her family, Fablehaven, and perhaps the world, Kendra must find the courage to do what she fears most."

---

Thoughts: I was very pleasantly surprised by Fablehaven. I was looking for a completely different book on the young adult shelves at the library when this one caught my eye. I had seen the cover many times before, but avoided picking it up because I assumed it was a Spiderwick wanna-be. This time, however, I decided that it might be worth taking a peek at, and brought it home with me.

Boy was I glad!

I found myself readily enjoying the story Brandon Mull put forth in Fablehaven, and am looking forward to returning to the library ASAP so that I can get my hands on the rest of the series.

I thought that Mull's characters were engaging and consistent. Seth was a very frustrating yet endearing younger brother, and Kendra's fears and concerns were very relatable. I remember being a lot like her at that age. Mull wrote them in very believable ways, and I was never jolted out of the story through thinking that a character had done something out of their nature. (One of my biggest pet peeves for a book.)

The fairies and other magical creatures in the books were both parts wonderfully fantastic and terribly creepy when they needed to be. This book might concern some very young readers, but I do not think that they would find it overly frightening. The book balanced the scary parts of the story with light-hearted scenes and characters who looked out for each other.

I appreciated that, even though Seth was the reckless, rule-disobeying character, it was obvious that Kendra still cared for her younger brother. Sure, they had their sibling moments, and there were times when she would threaten to tattle on him, but I never got annoyed at these moments like I have with some other young adult books. Instead, I felt like both Seth and the reader knew enough about what was going on to see that Kendra was coming from a place of genuine concern and not trying to "play mother" as the older sibling.

Another thing I appreciated was that there were genuine consequences for every action. Whatever that action may be, something reacted to it. Both positively and negatively.

Overall I would say this is a highly enjoyable read and I will definitely be looking in to the rest of the series.

---

Favorite Quote(s): 
- Grandpa became very serious. "None of these creatures are good. Not the way we think of good. None are safe. Much of morality is peculiar to mortality. The best creatures here are merely not evil." (page 80)

- "We did not really live, not like mortals. We dreamed." (page 91)

- "Evil likes darkness."
"Why is that?" Seth asked.
[...] thought about the question a moment before answering. "Because evil likes to hide." (page 284)

---

Discussion Questions: (Please note, though I do my best to keep spoilers out of my reviews, discussion questions are by nature for people who have read the book and may contain spoilers. Read them at your own risk! Also, if you are responding to one of the discussion questions in the comments below, please put SPOILERS at the beginning of any portions of your comment that might ruin the book for other interested parties. Thank you!)

- What did you think of Grandfather's way of seeing if his grandchildren were the right type of people for Fablehaven? Do you think his plan was a good one or a bad one?

- What did you think of the way the fairies treated Seth after he accidentally turned one of them in to an imp? Do you think his punishment was the right one?

- Why do you think Kendra was able to get through to the Fairy Queen?

- Do you think Lena is happy with her fate?

---

What do you think of the Fablehaven series? Do you like Fablehaven or Spiderwick better?

- Faye

Review: Rare Beasts by Charles Ogden

Title: Rare Beasts (Edgar & Ellen #1)
Author: Charles Ogden
Rating: ***
ISBN: 1416914099
Genre: Juvenile - Fantasy - Humor
Summary: From Goodreads: "Twins Edgar and Ellen live alone -- their parents disappeared years ago, and who can blame them?--in the quaint, little town of Nod's Limbs, in a grim, gray house overlooking the cemetery and the junkyard. They spend their days avoiding Heimertz, the mysterious accordion-playing caretaker; pestering Pet, a hairy, one-eyed creature of indeterminate species and gender; and wrecking havoc on the hapless citizens of Nod's Limbs.

But wrecking havoc can incur expenses, so the twins come up with a unique fund-raising scheme: They'll nab the pets of Nod's Limbs and transform them into exotic animals they can sell for big bucks. Not a bad plan, if one of the purloined pets wasn't a lethargic python with a raging appetite..."

Thoughts: This is a twisted and humorous piece of juvenile fiction, but I would be careful about the maturity and discernment of the children I allowed to read it. Edgar and Ellen are downright dangerous and brutal in the ways they play together at times. (We're talking weapons and other less-than-safe activities.) They also absolutely delight in mischief and misery -- their home is falling apart and they love it that way, they also relish the pitiful cries of Nod's Limbs' children as they search for their lost pets.

As an adult, I found parts of it humorous. It reminded me of a simplified version of the Series of Unfortunate Events books, though this time the children are the ones with the power. Adults are not displayed as especially repulsive, but nor are they displayed as intelligent - almost like Roald Dahl loves to display the adult figures in his books.

Overall, I thought it was a decent attempt at juvenile fiction. Definitely not near the best that I have read, but I would not be opposed to suggesting it to a child with the ability to discern what it meant for humor and what is actually appropriate about the story.


Favorite Quote(s): None.

---

What is your opinion of twisted children's literature?

- Faye

Book Fail: The Edge and the Light by Queenie Chan

Title: Legend of Zelda: The Edge and the Light

Author: Queenie Chan

Rating: *

ISBN: 9781310342622

Genre: Fan Fiction - Fantasy - Graphic Novel
Source: Apple App Store - Free Book

---

Summary: From Goodreads: "The once-bountiful kingdom of Hyrule is in a crisis. It has been plagued by poor harvests, natural disasters, and now a missing Princess Zelda - Queen Regent to the throne. Into the fray wanders Link, a former champion of Hyrule who vanished over 10 years ago under mysterious circumstances he refuses to speak of. Just what is the cause of all this unrest? Find out in this illustrated prose story!"

---

Thoughts: I almost NEVER don't finish a book, but I couldn't bring myself to finish this one. The writing was too strange, beyond mixing chunks of text with more graphic novel style sections. But when the author changed tenses for a section from third person to third person (without reason), I gave up. I'm sad because I love the Legend of Zelda games, and I was even willing to try to see the characters through the slant she was using, but I just couldn't stick through all of that plus poor writing. Maybe I'm just too big of a fan of the games.

And I just read the summary while writing this up. Maybe the way that was written should have given me some hints...

---

What prevents you from finishing a book?

- Faye